When a misunderstanding makes you pretend to be engaged with a cowboy…
Synopsis
She’s not getting hitched. He’s just here for the ride.
Whitney’s life is not going to plan. Her romantic comedy novel isn’t selling, her career feels stuck, and by the time she realises she’s in love with her best friend and roommate, Andy, he’s back from his work trip with a fiancée – and a wedding date that is alarmingly soon.
Enter Jake: a cowboy with his own problems, including a country estate he’s desperate to buy and an owner who doesn’t trust developers – or men without roots. When a viral moment throws Whitney and Jake together, they strike a deal. Whitney gets the real-life love story publishers want. Jake gets to look like a committed, family-minded man who belongs at Rosewood. All they have to do is pretend they’re in love.
As Andy’s wedding approaches, Whitney uncovers a plot twist that could change everything for him – but the romcom she’s acting out with Jake is starting to feel dangerously real.
Falling for your best friend is complicated, but riding off into the sunset with a cowboy is pure fiction… Right?
My review
Whitney is at the moment struggling a little bit in life. While there aren’t any major issues, the fact that she is having troubles with selling her romantic comedy novel, causes her a few headaches. And when due some eye – opening moments, she realizes that she is in love with her best friend and roommate Andy, Whitney does not know what to do. Because years ago, she pushed Andy clearly in the friendzone, yet now she knows that no one gets her better than he does. But when Andy comes back from a work trip, Whitney is ready to come clean about her feelings, weren’t it that Andy now has a fiancée and there is already a wedding date, in the near future. At the estate where the wedding is going to take place, Whitney rather embarrassingly meets Jake, an actual cowboy. Unfortunately, their meeting is gone viral, making people believe a romantic engagement took place, Whitney and Jake both see this as an opportunity for the both of them. Because for Whitney not only is this a chance to show publishers a real – life love story, and perhaps make Andy a bit jealous. And for Jake, it is a perfect chance to show what a committed, family – minded man he is, as his plan is to buy the Rosewood Estate, but from an owner who doesn’t trust men without roots. So their fake engagement is perfect for both Whitney and Jake, it also means a lot of pretending. However, the better they get to know each other, the less pretend is taking place… And when a plot twist involving Andy could change everything, what story line is the one to be followed?
Starting a book written by Portia MacIntosh, is knowing beforehand you will be laughing, gasping for air, rooting for the main characters and just have the best of times. And for me personally, when an actual cowboy will be involved, my ovaries too are ready! 😊
Whitney is such an easy character to like. She is down – to – earth, kind, funny and also a bit sarcastic. And the fact that she is also an author, made me like her even more. She also has the best kind of friends, where Andy is also her roommate, share the same hobbies, and even without a word they understand each other. And how peculiar it also may sound for a friendship between man and woman, they tell each other everything, they hear each other all the time.
And JJ is not only Whitney agent, but a real friend. Because she is the person that will push Whitney out of her comfort zone, even challenging her to go out in the dating pool. JJ is a bit unhinged, acting before she thinks at moments. But JJ is what Whitney needs, as she sometimes needs that little nudge.
And it is that same JJ that makes Whitney realize what her feelings for Andy are. Now, I have to admit, while on paper Whitney and Andy may seem like a perfect match, it felt also a little bit that JJ is the one making Whitney ‘feel’ things for Andy. Because if JJ hadn’t put that little seed in Whitney’s head, Whitney would have never gone that direction.
Of course as a reader I already knew that Andy would return home with a fiancée. But just as Whitney, I could not be more surprised at the speed of it all (yes yes, I knew it beforehand, but still…). And just like Whitney, I found several moments truly cringy (e.g. the nicknames). Cringy but also hilarious 😊.
Talking about hilarious… our first introduction of Jake… hilarious, but definitely also swoon – worthy! Poor Whitney, falling into the fountain like that, but what a rescue by Jake! I don’t think that a rescue could be any more heroic or ovary-exploding! 😊
Jake is in a way the typical cowboy, with his “ma’am”, loves horses perhaps even more than humans. But he is also clearly a man with his heart at the right place. Because I don’t think that many people would be leaving their home behind to ‘just’ be closer to a parent.
And I liked it how Jake wants to do the right thing, but also doesn’t want to ignore his essence, with a passion for horses. He somehow wants to find the perfect balance between remaining himself but also being here for his father. What a man!
What else what I found hilarious, was how Jake rescuing Whitney is captured and how online it gets a completely different storyline! How a simple rescue transforms into a very romantic proposal.
Of course I could understand why Whitney and Jake decide to keep up the pretence. Because them pretending to be a couple deep in love, also ready for the next step, would help the both of them to achieve their goals.
I found it sweet and funny at the same time, seeing how Jake and Whitney are trying to make everyone believe how much in love they are. And meanwhile, while faking it, they learn just how much they are alike. They care about the same things, share the same opinions and they also just seem to understand each other.
As so often in books (and in reality too) the more time is spent with someone, the quicker feelings are changing, especially is there is a lot of faking taking place. And seeing that shift taking place between Whitney and Jake truly warmed my heart. Even how impossible it may seem to have feelings changing, they show us that in fact, it is possible.
It is clear that I truly enjoyed reading this story, had many laughs and loved the sweet, heartwarming moments. Portia MacIntosh wrote an amazing story, about how faking it perhaps can result in making it. And that feelings can grow really fast, and that is okay, as long as the feelings are genuine, honest and real.

























