Everyone is innocent until proven guilty, right?
Synopsis
1968, Sicily. Just months after a terrible earthquake has destroyed the mountain town of Gibellina, Enzo and his wife Irene Borgata are making their way back to the family home, Villa Alba del Ciliegio, on roads overlooked by the eerie backdrop of the flattened ghost town. When their car breaks down, Enzo leaves his young wife to go and get help, but when he returns there is no trace of Irene. No body, no sign of a struggle, nothing.
Present Day. TV showman and true crime aficionado Milo Conti is Italy’s darling, uncovering and solving historic crimes for his legion of fans. When he turns his attention to the story of the missing Irene Borgata, accusing her husband of her murder, Enzo’s daughter Maddi asks her childhood friend, retired detective Jane Cobain, for help to prove her father’s innocence. But the tale Jane discovers is murky: mafia meetings, infidelity, mistaken identity, grief and unshakable love. As the world slowly closes in on the claustrophobic Villa Alba del Ciliegio, and the house begins to reveal its secrets, will the Borgata family wish they’d never asked Jane to investigate? And what did happen to Enzo’s missing wife Irene?
Bestselling author Louise Douglas returns with an irresistibly compelling, intriguing and captivating tale of betrayal, love, jealousy and the secrets buried in every family history..
My review
In 1968, Irene Borgata disappeared after a car break and her husband Enzo went to get help. With absolutely no evidence at all, the case turned into a classical cold case.
That is until in 2003 an Italian TV showman, Milo Conti, make it his next case – to – be – solved. Hin finger points into the direction of Enzo. With the people getting more and more agitated, Enzo’s daughter Maddi asks her friend and retired detective April Cobain for help and proving Enzo’s innocence.
Initially rather reluctant, April decides to help out her childhood friend, only discovering that Villa Alba holds more secrets she thought…
With the clock ticking for the big revealing TV show, will April find the evidence of Enzo’s innocence? And what did truly happen to Irene?
With this kind of blurb, it’s rather easy to catch my attention. Especially when there is so much mystery… How could someone just disappear into thin air? Why is there nothing to be found, not a body, not a drop of blood, or even a ransom note?
And then I am only talking about the disappearance itself, because it’s clear that Villa Alba holds many more secrets, ready to be all revealed!
It was fascinating to read the dual timeline, seeing how Irene was adapting into her new life, just married to Enzo, and seeing how April is trying to discover what really happened with Irene, with a deadline to keep in mind too.
I liked how the author made a change in the traditional dual time line, by showing us Irene’s thoughts and not just telling us how Irene’s life was.
That made me understand Irene better, seeing her struggles. And not only of those adapting to a life in Sicily, but also her emotional struggles.
We see how Irene got her heart broken even before she met Enzo, but how she slowly is picking up the pieces of her life again. She does her best to be happy with Enzo and his family, but it’s not easy to enter a typical Sicilian family as a foreigner. And it’s not easy when your heart still belongs to someone else…
We see her many struggles, but also her little moments of happiness. How she find it with the horses, but also falling in love with little Maddalena, how they form a unique bond between the two of them.
A Maddalena that even in 2003 is struggling with the disappearance of the only mother – figure she has known. So I understood why she reached out to April when a TV show would dedicate an episode to Irene’s disappearance.
I liked to see April’s determination to get to the bottom of the story. Even if she is connected with the family, and cares not only about Maddi but also Enzo, she won’t allow that connection to stop the truth from coming out. Whether it’s that Enzo truly killed his wife or if there was completely something else going on.
As someone who has read and watched several mystery – stories, I have to admit that the big revelation didn’t come as a complete surprise. Throughout the story we get a few clues that can give it already away, if you are paying attention.
Yet even if my hunch turned out to be right, this story kept me pushing to read more. The need to be proven right was just too high.
And while it was certainly about finding out the truth about a cold case, it was for sure also about the strength of love, even lost loves.




























